SEO Pricing – difference between £300 and £4,000 a month ?

Written by Fraser McCulloch.

Home : SEO : SEO Pricing – difference between £300 and £4,000 a month ?

One SEO agency proposes £300 a month and another sends a proposal for a £4000 a month; what’s the difference ?

Let’s step back a moment and figure out what you really want.

The goal is to deliver traffic from Google

After hiring an seo agency or expert you want more traffic from the search engines, right ?

But how much monthly search traffic do you need ?

  • 1,000 visits ?
  • 10,000 visits ?

Get instant traffic from Google Ads

You can instantly get that traffic by running a pay per click campaign with Google Ads.

This company pays £14 for one click with Google Ads.

So, 1,000 visits costs them £14,000.

And 10,000 visits costs £140,000.

Google Adwords will pretty much guarantee that traffic so long as you have the funds.

But what if you’re a law firm and the cost per click is £320 to £415 ?

If you’re selling soap or clothes the cost per click will be much, much lower.

What’s SEO Traffic worth ?

Search traffic has a monetary value.

Stop paying for Google Ads and the traffic stops.

This company specialises in loft conversions and pods.

A builder charges between £30,000 per loft conversion project.

The owners want 2 new jobs per month.

That’s £60,000 a month or £720,000 per year in revenue.

To get 2 jobs, they need to convert their traffic into website enquiries.

Let’s say 1 in 10 enquiries become a customer.

Divide 2 enquiries by 10% conversion ie: 20 enquiries every month.

If they convert 2% of their website traffic into enquiries that means they need 1,000 visits per month to reach their goal.


They would pay Google Ads £14,000 a month to get 1000 visits to possibly deliver £60,000 a month in revenue.

That’s £14,000 in ad costs for 1,000 visits every month.

I doubt many property developers could sustain that budget every month.

And that’s where organic search traffic comes in.

For every paid click, there’s 10 organic clicks

Look at this chart.

  • 4.42% of clicks come from Ad clicks
  • 45.25% of clicks come from organic clicks
  • 50.33% are zero click searches

Very rarely do people search, click and buy immediately

If you’re considering an extension to your home, you’re going to do a lot of homework beforehand.

  • Is an extension worth it ?
  • Do I need planning permission?
  • Do I have the funds to pay for it ?
  • What about design, architecture etc

It’s highly unlikely you will decide today, out of the blue, to click an advert or call a property developer.

Having done a little research about lofts, I know that the top 10 pages in Google (UK) get, on average, 1307 organic visits a month for people searching “plans for loft conversion”.

And 623 people clicking on top pages about “planning permission for loft conversion”.

There’s 540 people clicking on pages about “loft conversion ideas”

Now we both know there’s an estimated 2470 clicks that exist around these 3 topics.

As you can see from the click forecast above, there’s an estimated 51,749 organic visits possible.

Publish the best content that answers the search query

There are hundreds of pages that already answer the queries.

  • Plans for loft conversion
  • Planning permission for loft conversion.

You need to produce an answer in your page content that’s better and more useful than the top ranked pages to outrank them.

The first 2 pages have written over 3,000 words because answering the query “plans for loft conversion” isn’t a simple answer.

How long to get ranked on page 1 ?

According to Ahrefs, only 5.7% of pages will get ranked on page 1 in 60 to 120 days.

If you do nothing with your pages, it’s going to take a year before you start ranking on page 1.

Here’s how long it took this website to start seeing traffic because they sat back and did nothing.

You don’t have 12 to 24 months to wait.

Promote your pages to improve rankings

In order to speed up your rankings you will need to promote your pages and earn links.

Google tends to rank pages, not websites.

Typically well known or the websites with the most domain authority appear in the top results.

But if you can earn links to pages you’re trying to rank higher and faster THEN you stand a good chance of getting onto page 1.

Links to your page from industry relevant, high authority links are the best links to earn.

A link to a page about loft conversions from an estate agent, architect blog or home improvement website would be ideal.

And the only way you’ll earn those links will be to identify people likely to link a useful asset on your page.

A useful asset they will link to could be an image, calculator, statistic or checklist about lofts.


When people visit and read your page, you need a process to turn site visitors into subscribers.

Make them an offer in exchange for their name and email.

So, if they were searching for “plans for loft conversion” you’re going to make an offer on your page such as 

After they fill in the form you’ll deliver your plans or guide, you’ll add them to a database so you can follow up with them.

You already know they are not ready to buy immediately but you can educate and guide them through your sales process.

  • Introduce them to work you’ve done.
  • Share your social channels with them
  • Tell them about your architects, builders, interior designers
  • Explain the planning process
  • Recommend ways to finance a loft conversion
  • Give examples of customers who’ve added great value to their homes
  • Provide testimonials, accreditations and so on.
  • Invite them to an open day or tour of work you’ve done.

Track and Measure

You’ll want to keep updated on how you’re ranking in Google, how links are being earned, how your pages are converting and what your agency is doing to improve your leads.

Optimise and Improve

Let’s say new planning and building legislation is introduced and you’ve not updated your page.

Your rankings drop, traffic drops and less leads come into your business.

An SEO with their finger on the pulse can identify these changes and put recommendations in place to get your rankings and traffic back on course.

Similarly, you have pages stuck on page 2 getting no traffic, the SEO can diagnose issues and implement solutions to get onto page 1.

Gaps and Opportunities

After a few years successfully designing and building loft conversions for clients you notice some clients come back and ask you to convert their basement or garage.

You don’t offer these services on your current website.

Or there are planning restrictions that prevent you converting lofts.

SEO experts can identify gaps and opportunities like these.

Or your competitors are getting traffic to topics and pages you don’t have.

£300 or £4000 a month for SEO Services?

Here’s a comparison of some average seo costs and a £4000 a month retainer.

Service£300 a month£4,000 a month
Click Research & ForecastNoIncluded
Best content to answer search queriesNoYes
Promotion and link earningNoYes
Website conversionNo Yes
SEO ImprovementMaybeYes
Tracking, reporting and measurementYesYes
Gap and opportunity analysis?Yes

£4,000 per month is equivalent to the monthly salary you’d pay a marketing manager; someone with less than 5 years commercial experience.

And not someone who specialises in growing unpaid organic traffic.

Just because you can generate traffic with Google Ads there is no guarantee you can convert that traffic into leads or sales.

If you do use Google Ads your website will still need to invest in content development for your web pages.

So you may as well create content based around what people are searching and click on.


If you need leads urgently then invest in Google Ads but you can still do both PPC and SEO.

If the website or business is new with little traffic, spend money on both PPC and SEO.

Over time you can reduce your PPC spend as organic traffic starts to grow.

A £4000 monthly retainer for SEO is outcome focus

Search for and look at any £300 a month seo service.

They’ll offer you monthly reports, meetings and actions that will make very little difference to your traffic and zero difference to your lead conversions.

Using example above, the aim of a £4000 a month seo expert is 

  • to deliver you £14,000 a month worth of traffic
  • 1000 visits a month 
  • and the enquiries you need to generate £60,000 of revenue per month.

Other SEO Pricing Models

No one jumps straight into monthly retainers with seo agencies; that’s like getting married before going on a few dates.

Start with a project-based pricing to tackle one problem.

That’s what I do with my click forecasting strategy.

Or ask the agency to work on a piece of content or content creation for a group of pages.

Or do a test link building campaign.

Over a series of dates you’ll get to see how you both get along and work together.

If you’re a good fit with each other, then work on a continuous basis.